top of page

How Personal Injury Settlements Are Calculated in NY

Writer: Alex MalteseAlex Maltese

A personal injury settlement is a monetary agreement reached between an injured individual and the responsible party or their insurance company to compensate for damages incurred due to negligence or wrongdoing.


In New York, determining the value of a personal injury settlement is a complex process that considers various factors. Below is more information.


Types of Damages

Types of Damages


Personal injury settlements generally encompass two primary categories of damages:


Economic Damages

These are quantifiable financial losses directly resulting from the injury and include:


Medical Expenses

Past and future medical bills encompass hospital stays, surgeries, medications, physical therapy, rehabilitation, and any necessary medical equipment may fall into this category.


Some examples are expenses for long-term care, such as in-home care, assisted living, or nursing home care, if required due to the injuries.


Lost Wages

These refer to current and future income lost due to the inability to work, including both lost wages and diminished earning capacity, which can be particularly significant for individuals who are unable to return to their previous profession due to their injuries.


This calculation may involve considering factors such as the individual's age, occupation, earning potential, and expected career trajectory.


Property Damage

It's any cost associated with repairing or replacing damaged property, such as vehicles, clothing, or personal belongings.


Non-Economic Damages

These are more subjective and aim to compensate for intangible losses, such as:


Pain and Suffering

This encompasses a wide range of emotional and physical consequences of the injury, including:


  • Physical pain: Acute and chronic pain, discomfort, and suffering, such as pain from injuries themselves, as well as pain associated with medical procedures and treatments.

  • Emotional distress: Anxiety, depression, PTSD, and other mental health conditions that may arise from the injury, such as emotional distress related to the impact of the injury on the individual's relationships, social life, and overall quality of life.

  • Loss of enjoyment of life: Limitations on the ability to participate in hobbies, recreational activities, and other aspects of daily life, such as the inability to engage in sports, travel, spend time with family and friends, or enjoy other previously cherished activities.


Loss of Consortium

This is the compensation for the loss of companionship, intimacy, and emotional support for the spouses or partners of the injured person.


Such damages can include the loss of household services, affection, and sexual intimacy, as well as the emotional impact of witnessing their partner's suffering.


Factors Influencing Personal Injury Settlement Amounts


Several key factors significantly influence the amount of a personal injury settlement in New York, including:


The Severity of Injuries

The severity of the injuries sustained directly impacts the potential settlement amount.

Catastrophic injuries, such as traumatic brain injuries, spinal cord injuries, severe burns, and amputations, often result in substantial settlements due to extensive medical care, long-term disability, and significant pain and suffering.


Factors considered within injury severity include:


  • Permanent disability or disfigurement

  • Long-term pain and suffering

  • Loss of limbs or other bodily functions

  • Need for ongoing medical care and rehabilitation

  • Impact on the individual's ability to perform activities of daily living (ADLs), such as bathing, dressing, and eating.


Liability

The degree of fault assigned to the responsible party directly impacts the settlement amount.


New York operates under a comparative negligence system, meaning the injured party's compensation may be reduced based on their own percentage of fault in the accident.


Strength of Evidence

A strong case with compelling evidence of negligence significantly increases the likelihood of a favorable settlement. This evidence may include:


  • Eyewitness testimony

  • Medical records documenting the extent of injuries and treatment, including doctor's notes, hospital records, and medical bills.

  • Accident reports

  • Photographs and videos of the accident scene and injuries

  • Expert witness testimony from medical professionals (such as doctors, surgeons, and rehabilitation specialists), accident reconstruction specialists, and economists.


Insurance Policy Limits

The available insurance coverage limits the maximum amount that can be recovered from the responsible party.


It's crucial to understand the insurance policy limits of all parties involved in the accident, including automobile insurance, homeowner's insurance, and commercial insurance policies.


Negotiation Skills 

The skills and experience of the personal injury attorney representing the injured party play a critical role in negotiating a fair settlement. This experience can also help explain how car accident settlements are calculated in NY.


A skilled attorney can effectively:


  • Gather and present evidence to support the client's claim.

  • Communicate effectively with insurance adjusters and opposing counsel.

  • Advocate for the client's best interests throughout the negotiation process.

  • Understand and utilize relevant legal precedents and case law.

  • Employ effective negotiation strategies, such as mediation and arbitration, to reach a mutually agreeable settlement.


Calculating Non-Economic Damages


Calculating non-economic damages, such as pain and suffering, is often the most challenging aspect of a personal injury settlement.


New York law doesn't provide a specific formula for determining pain and suffering damages. However, attorneys often rely on the "multiplier method" as a general guideline. For more information, the Law Office of Carl Maltese may be able to help.


This method involves multiplying the total amount of economic damages (medical expenses, lost wages, etc.) by a factor between 1.5 and 5.


The appropriate multiplier is determined based on a variety of factors, including:


  • The severity of the injuries

  • The duration and intensity of pain and suffering

  • The impact of the injuries on the victim's daily life and future prospects

  • The presence of any permanent disabilities or disfigurement

  • The victim's age and life expectancy

  • The presence of any aggravating factors, such as the defendant's reckless or intentional conduct.


The Importance of Legal Representation for a Personal Injury Case

The Importance of Legal Representation for a Personal Injury Case


Handling a personal injury claim can be overwhelming for an individual who has already suffered significant trauma, so it's wise to hire a lawyer.


This is what a personal injury attorney can help with:


  • Thorough investigation, including:

    • Accident reconstruction

    • Obtaining surveillance footage

    • Consulting with experts

  • Accurate damage assessment, which involves:

    • Obtaining and reviewing medical records

    • Consulting with medical experts

    • Calculating lost wages and earning capacity

  • Negotiation and advocacy, which involves:

    • Communicating effectively with the insurance company

    • Developing a strong settlement demand

    • Exploring Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) options

  • Trial preparation, focusing on:

    • Preparing and filing court documents

    • Conducting depositions

    • Preparing for trial

    • Representing the client in court


Find Experienced New York Personal Injury Lawyers at The Law Office of Carl Maltese


If you or a loved one has been injured due to the negligence of another, The Law Office of Carl Maltese can give you a hand.


Our experienced personal injury attorneys in Long Island, New York, have a proven track record of success in securing substantial settlements for our clients.


Do you think the case should be taken to trial? We can also help you build and file a strong personal injury lawsuit to recover the compensation you deserve. Contact us today and schedule a free consultation!

bottom of page